Matters Arising

Jul 24

Baseball

(HEATHER and STEPHANIE are sitting in the stands of Yankee Stadium)

HEATHER

Do you think Alex is going to hit his 600th home run tonight?

STEPHANIE

I don’t really care about that.  I’m here to see Jeter…

HEATHER

How can you not care?  Six hundred home runs is historic.

STEPHANIE

It’s historic for guys who did it without taking steroids.  Not for guys who did.

HEATHER

Wow, that’s harsh.

STEPHANIE

It’s like saying a guy who dunks on a five foot basket is doing something great.  You can’t cheat and get rewarded.

HEATHER

But plenty of other guys did steroids without being able to hit six hundred home runs.

STEPHANIE

But there are clearly guys who did not take steroids who hit six hundred, and it’s not fair to put any cheaters in the same category.   Babe Ruth did not take steroids.

HEATHER

How do you know?  Maybe he took something…

STEPHANIE

All he took was hot dogs and beer.  They didn’t have steroids in the thirties.  

HEATHER

Yeah, that’s true.  Same for Willie Mays… he didn’t take steroids.

STEPHANIE

Exactly.  So to see Barry Bonds on the top of the all time home run list is an insult to Hank Aaron… and the Babe, and Willie Mays…

HEATHER

How about the Hall of Fame?

STEPHANIE

Maybe we can start a hall of fame for cheaters.

HEATHER

That would be a big hall…

STEPHANIE

Yeah…

HEATHER

So you wouldn’t put any of these guys into the Hall of Fame?  Rodriguez, Sosa, McGwire?

STEPHANIE

None of those guys.  Keep them out, put in Griffey, Jeter, guys like that…

HEATHER

I never knew you were such a passionate fan.

STEPHANIE

The whole point of baseball is its history.  If you can’t compare todays’ guys to former players, the whole thing is a waste of time.

HEATHER

How about in other areas?  Like, am I cheating by using electricity, when two hundred years ago they didn’t have electricity?

STEPHANIE

Are you serious?

HEATHER

I’m just asking….

STEPHANIE

I don’t even know how to answer that.

HEATHER

It was just a question.

STEPHANIE

Okay, whatever…

(The End)